WHEN CONTROLS CREATE RISK: A REVIEW OF CONTROL PROBLEMS UNDERLYING OPERATIONAL RISK IN BANKING

Pdf: DRMJ vol15 no02 2026 – Clanek 2

DOI:

doi:10.17708/DRMJ.2026.v15n02a02

Excerpt:

Operational risk losses continue to expose persistent weaknesses in how banks manage and control risk, despite increasingly sophisticated regulatory frameworks. This study examines how behavioural management control problems contribute to the emergence and management of operational risk in banking. Using the Object of Control framework as a theoretical lens, we systematically review research published between 1995 and 2025 to explore how the design and use of management control systems (MCS) influence operational risk management (ORM) outcomes. Synthesising 59 studies across design and use, rules and procedures, structures, incentives, and culture, we show that regulatory‐driven control architectures enhance accountability but often shift ORM toward auditability and compliance, producing procedural rigidity and reduced learning. We develop a two‐stage explanation of how control problems translate into persistent operational risk exposure: first, design–use misalignment displaces the preventive and mitigating purposes of ORM and transforms risk controls into symbolic assurance; second, structural fragmentation or centralisation, misaligned incentives, and cultural norms stabilise this rigidity by weakening feedback loops and normalising compliance‐oriented behaviour. The study advances a behavioural–systems perspective on operational risk, highlighting that resilience depends on aligning control design with enacted use and maintaining adaptive learning alongside regulatory assurance.

Pages:

35‐61